
In retrospect, it seems like I’m misremembering the first time I heard Grace Potter & The Nocturnals. I was trekking across the massive Bonnaroo concert grounds in 2006, in a haze or daze or some kind of state of unreality, trying to dodge a sun that I was starting to think was out to get me, when I felt fiery guitar solos and rich organ tones flying over me. “Is Crazy Horse doing an unannounced show in the middle of the day?” I wondered. “Does Crazy Horse even have an organ player?” If I’d known about Wikipedia then, I’d probably have wished I could’ve used it. I didn’t, so I instead wandered towards the source of the sound like it was a trail of breadcrumbs, and I was a character in a children’s book set in the middle of blazing hot Tennessee.
The sound, as these things turn out, was Grace Potter & The Nocturnals, a four piece outfit from Waitsfield, Vermont, a town that’s small even as far as Vermont standards go. Singer/guitarist/Hammond B-3 addict Potter and her band, guitar player Scott Tournet, bassist Bryan Dondero and drummer Matthew Burr, work out of a hippie-like compound – “Potterville,” Grace calls it - that seems like a cross between the Shire and Big Pink (“Potter has a lot of Tolkien in her blood,” Tournet jokes). The band members were all in their twenties when they released their first two records, Original Soul and Nothing But The Water, which is sort of remarkable until you listen to the albums and realize that they were recorded a few years ago and not a few decades ago. Then, it’s extremely remarkable.
They are a band unashamedly steeped in their influences, and, for a rock and roll band, they’ve got all the right ones: the Stones, the Who, Zeppelin, The Band, Neil Young – and not the shitty stuff, either. “We love Neil, but you totally have to call your heroes out,” Tournet says, an important philosophical point in the band’s approach. Potter and the Nocturnals manage to be appreciative without being reverent. This isn’t one of those new rock bands that sounds like it’s covering all the songs Led Zeppelin never get around to writing (or stealing from Willie Dixon, as it were). More interestingly, they’re changing, and in a way that might well make them better rather than weirder.
While there was a strong whiff of the musical lovechild of J.J. Cale and Bonnie Raitt in the swampy guitars and raggedly laidback vocals of Nothing But The Water, GP&TN’s newest record (and, after a long courtship, their first with a major label) is altogether trickier to pin down.
Released in August, This Is Somewhere (a play on a classic Neil Young record title) is an album that – at its best parts - sounds like the last days of summer, like wistful reflection (on tracks like “Apologies” and “Big White Gate”), like slow burn Kerouacian soul gazing through car windows (“Stop The Bus”), like jagged guitar solos and bouncing rhythm sections. And, then, there are Potter’s vocals. Warm, revealing, with seductive whispers and soaring screams and a hell of a range in between, like Norah Jones with a pulse of 160.
During their live set opening for Gov’t Mule on Friday night, she’s the obvious focal point of the band and not just because she’s the only one who isn’t wearing a hat. On the other hand, good looks – even great looks – don’t construct a groove or make a smooth song transition. To start their too brief 45 minute performance (the band members initially thought they had an hour, then hastily restructured their set when they found out they didn’t), the band strolled out on the stage to a half-filled Bank of America Pavilion and tore into “Stop The Bus” like the only people in the room were the ones onstage.
How do they psych themselves up for performances like that? “I’ve been really into voodoo lately,” Dondero cracks before the show.

While Tournet mentions influences like Roy Buchanan and Neil Young, his guitar work – the strutting riffs, lyrical lead licks and the kind of scorching solos that sound like they’re ripped rather than played – recalls the concision and versatility of Mike Campbell, ace guitar man for Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers. In any case, he, Dondero and Burr crank out the kind of rhythm that would serve as a steady foundation for a house. Dondero, though not a flashy performer, knows just how to hit the sweet spot with his bass line. When they crack open (the sadly ITunes-only Somewhere track) “If I Was From Paris,” it’s a six-minute lesson in how to combine thrash, hooks and percussive ass kicking.
Burr later points out that he has a stuffed doll of Animal, one of music’s great underrated drummers, on his set, and it’s easy to see the influence. Though the band is capable of more thoughtful, atmospheric songs when they stretch out, there’s no time for that now as they move into “I’ve Been Watching You,” where the rapid fire sputter of guitar shrieks from Tournet finally betrays that Neil Young worship. As the crowd stands on its feet and Burr throws one of his cymbals (“a direct effect of watching
The Kids Are Alright,” he admits), the band rides the feedback wave into a song built for set closing. “Nothing But The Water,” which starts with Potter a cappella, eventually moves into a four-way drum solo and finally concludes with the crowd and band chanting the chorus – minus any microphones – until Potter, Tournet, Dondero and Burr exit stage left, taking with them the adoration of at least a few hundred new fans.
“What do I think of Grace Potter?” a Gov’t Mule fan says, echoing my question to him during Mule’s set. “I think she’s one of the hottest singers I’ve seen onstage in a while.”
And, also: “No shit! Oh my god,” when I tell him that she’ll be out in a moment to sing Neil Young’s “Southern Man” with Warren Haynes and company. Haynes, who looks about four shades paler up close, proposed the idea backstage before the show, and Potter had to double check the words to the second verse online. When she joins The Mule onstage, she nails it, screaming with the strip-the-paint-off-the-walls urgency of a white, “Gimme Shelter”-era Merry Clayton. It’s a good thing that the song closes out the first set; Mule certainly didn’t have anything in its arsenal to top it.
…………………………………
Backstage before the show, the band is no less lively and uninhibited than they will be in front of the crowd. A short interview with Potter, Tournet and Dondero turns into a forty-five minute shit-shooting session that lasts until soundcheck and then continues after the show with drummer Burr. As they joke and swear and laughingly interrupt each others’ stories, the band’s freewheeling openness is disarming and endearing. Burr, in particular, has a kind of sincerity that’s hard to find anywhere, let alone backstage in a band’s lounge at a rock concert.

After I make my way to meet them at the labyrinthine BoA Pavilion – a process that includes (no joke) taking a quasi-secret passage - Potter greets me in the interview room and, as Dondero and Tournet enter, tries to decide where she wants to hang a scarf to enliven the drab surroundings. Pausing to belch occasionally – she’s in a band with three others guys, after all – Potter and her band mates dizzily relay the story of their appearance on
The Tonight Show with Jay Leno. The highlight of their potentially career-making national television performance? It wasn’t actually being on
The Tonight Show.
It was meeting (Leno bandleader) Kevin Eubanks’ guitar tech – longtime Neil Young/Crazy Horse guitar player Frank “Poncho” Sampedro.
“Claire Danes was begging Bryan for his autograph, waiting outside his door, trying so hard to get his autograph, and Bryan was like, ‘Leave me alone! I’m talking to Poncho’” Potter says. “Bob Saget’s like, ‘Hey guys, I want to talk to Poncho, too.’ And we’re like, ‘No! Saget, Poncho’s all ours.’”
“We have a very cool plan,” Tournet interjects when I ask about the band’s infrequent, though consistently epic live covers of Young’s “Cortez The Killer.” “We could give you the scoop,” he teases.
“Give him the scoop!” Potter insists.
“We exchanged phone numbers [with Poncho],” Tournet goes on. “He was super cool, he was super psyched that we even knew who he was and cared and loved his music, so when we’re out in L.A., our master plan is to get Warren [Haynes] and Poncho up for [a live cover of] “‘Cortez.’”
Considering that the last time I saw the band play “Cortez,” it clocked in at a towering 21 minutes and put new cracks in the floor of the Paradise Rock Club, the potential of that collaboration is kind of scary. Still, while the love for classic rock is unyielding, This Is Somewhere sounds less out of its time than its predecessors, a sign perhaps that the band is more comfortable in its own skin. And, also, that the members discovered albums that didn’t pre-date the 8-track.

“I think we’re opening up to the idea of listening to newer music,” Potter says. Before, “it was, ‘No, we don’t listen to anything except the Rolling Stones and Neil Young and Taj Mahal. It was like we had a rulebook, and the rulebook ended in 1975.”
“Ah, it was a great time,” Tournet says, mock wistful.
“What happened?” Potter asks. “Now we’re listening to fucking Kraftwerk.”
“Hey, hey, easy!” he responds.
Even with its modern influences, This Is Somewhere has that unique Nocturnals feel, the lived-in warmth of their other albums but some more polish too. And, also, a little bit of mystery, something I can’t quite put my finger on. A quick read through the liner notes offers a clue, a credit to a shadowy organization called the Booty Call Choir.
“It’s fucking me!” Potter exclaims, laughing. “We really wanted everybody to know they can dig deep and see who played what on the record and who was contributing what little pieces and parts to each song. And, I do sing a lot of backup, but I wanted to add a little myth in there that there were these hot mamas in the room to make it sound good.”
Perhaps realizing that admitting to a hoax is no way to create a myth, she backtracks. “It’s not me. It’s three women, and they would actually track [their vocals] naked.”
The band’s success hasn’t quite gone to their heads yet, fictional naked backup singers aside. Their dreams for the future don’t involve mansions or groupies or Scarface-sized mountains of blow. At least, not yet. (Tournet wants “a tour bus,” and Dondero simply hopes the band will be able to headline a full cross-country tour.) Citing bands like the Red Hot Chili Peppers and the White Stripes who achieved success on their own terms, Burr says the band is not looking for any easy cash-in, overnight sensation solution.
“It’s not like we’re going full-on through the pop machine, like Nickelback,” he concludes. “Like those awful corporate rock bands.”
Maybe it’s their intense touring schedule or the years they spent rejecting major label offers or maybe it’s some weird Vermont “to each according to his need” thing, but this isn’t a band that’s caught up in its own bullshit. Of course, the easiest way to avoid that is not to believe the bullshit to begin with.
“We haven’t ‘arrived,’” is the way Tournet characterizes it. “The last three years has been people telling us, ‘It’s happening.’”
“Money, we don’t make,” Potter insists. “We’re not there in any way on that level.”
“We always said from day one we didn’t want to blow up too quickly,” Tournet says.
“We didn’t take that Miller Lite commercial we were offered,” she says.
“Everyone in L.A. thinks you’re retarded for not wanting that,” he laments.
The band’s idealism – what Tournet says others have called their “naïveté” – sometimes conflicts with the desire to have their music touch as many people as possible. They try to thread that needle – they’ll do Grey’s Anatomy but probably not commercials for Exxon Mobil. But, when it comes to actually selling their stuff, it’s a bit more complicated, as Burr admits when talking about having the CD on the racks at Wal-Mart.

“One side of me thinks Wal-Mart has evildoings and evil ways,” he says. “But, there’s a part of me that realizes that is someone’s only store where they can go buy our CD. That’s their only music store.”
It’s an idea echoed by other band members. What it really comes down to is rock and roll populism of the best kind. You don’t make fans by deciding what sort of people you don’t want listening to you. After all, the music that Grace Potter & The Nocturnals are steeped in pre-dates the era of a thousand prefixes, of the indie- this and the alt- that.
“One thing that we did is we never set ourselves up to be Arcade Fire,” Potter continues. “We set ourselves up to be a good rock band that people want to see. We don’t want to be so exclusive that if a 45-year-old dude wants to bring his kids to the show, he’s going to get weird looks.”
“If he’s not wearing a scarf,” Tournet adds.
That’s not to say, though, that the band is afraid to piss people off. Far from it. The first track on the new album is the seductively deceptive “Ah Mary.” It opens with a J.J. Cale-style acoustic strum, and Potter’s breathy delivery: “She’s skilled at the art of deception and she knows it/she’s got dirty money that she plays with all the time.” The chorus contains one of the record’s killer lines, “She’ll bake you cookies/then she’ll burn your town,” immediately before the song ascends into full-on balls-out rock mode, as though Burr’s Keith Moon switch were flipped into the “on” position.
As the song draws to a close, however, Potter pulls out her first surprise in an album full of them. The shouts of “Mary Mary Mary” seamlessly turn into “America,” an emphatic condemnation of an ideology that runs much deeper than the war in Iraq. It’s the band’s first protest song. Sort of.
“I don’t like political songs,” Potter says. “I’m sick of hearing musicians pretending that they have any concept of how the world could become a better place, politically speaking. They don’t know what needs to go on to make it better.”
So then what gives with lines like “Call her a bully and she’ll blow up your whole damn playground”? There’s no mistaking the sentiment there. Potter says she prefers her route, subtler if not exactly subtle. Most sweeping, on-the-nose condemnations are neither constructive nor that interesting to listen to, she adds.
“I know plenty of Republicans and pretty conservative people who fucking love that song,” Potter explains. “I think maybe it’s slowly seeping into their sub-conscious, and they’ll play the record for their children and then their children will be destroyed forever.”

There’s the real scoop, folks. Today, it’s the Bank of America Pavilion for Grace Potter & The Nocturnals. Tomorrow? It’s the planet. World domination hasn’t rocked this hard since 1975.